Dobson's memoir of Horace Walpole opens not with a birth date but with a portrait: 'After Rosalba'—the pastel artist Rosalba Carriera—and a frontispiece that signals the book's interest in visual culture. The table of contents reveals a structure built around Walpole's social circles, his travels with Gray, and the gradual construction of Strawberry Hill. Dobson relies heavily on Walpole's own letters, quoting his self-deprecating remarks about The Mysterious Mother—'il n'y a pas de beaux sentiments'—and his claim that the tragedy's 'interest languishes from the first act to the last.' The memoir thus foregrounds Walpole's own critical voice, letting him comment on his own work.

The Strawberry Hill Press and Its Output

The appendix lists books printed at Strawberry Hill, but the excerpts show Dobson's interest in the press's intermittent activity. He notes that The Castle of Otranto and the Historic Doubts were not printed by Kirgate, Strawberry Hill's printer, while The Mysterious Mother was—in a run of only 50 copies. Dobson connects the press to Walpole's self-fashioning: the proprietor of a Gothic villa producing a Gothic novel has 'a certain congruity.' Yet he also records Walpole's own doubts about his tragedy, quoting his letter to Madame du Deffand that calls it 'des crimes, des repentis, et des horreurs.' The press emerges as a tool for limited circulation among friends, not commercial publication.

Walpole's Self-Contradictions as a Critic

Dobson highlights Walpole's shifting judgments on his own work. In a postscript to The Mysterious Mother, Walpole claims 'every scene tends to bring on the catastrophe'—contradicting his earlier admission that the play's interest 'languishes.' Dobson does not resolve this inconsistency but presents it as characteristic. He also includes Walpole's sweeping survey of English tragedy, from Shakespeare through Rowe and Southerne to Young, calling it 'a rapid and characteristic aperçu.' The memoir thus treats Walpole's critical pronouncements as data, not as settled truth, and lets readers weigh his self-assessments against the evidence of the works themselves.

The Social World of Letters and Gossip

The chapter headings promise 'Stage-gossip and Small-talk,' 'Ranelagh Gardens,' and 'High Life at Vauxhall.' Dobson embeds Walpole in a network of correspondents—Montagu, Gray, Madame du Deffand—and in events like the trial of the rebel lords after the '45. He quotes Walpole's letters about being robbed by James Maclean and the ensuing 'Maclean Mania.' The memoir does not isolate Walpole as a solitary genius; instead, it presents him as a node in a lively social and literary scene, where a tragedy's epilogue might be written for Mrs. Clive to speak 'in character.' Dobson's method is to let these details accumulate, building a portrait from the texture of daily life.

Readers coming to this memoir for a straightforward biography will find instead a layered account that foregrounds Walpole's own words and the material culture of his press. Dobson's method—quoting letters, noting contradictions, and listing the Strawberry Hill imprints—invites a skeptical engagement with Walpole's self-presentation. The book rewards those interested in how an eighteenth-century man of letters curated his own legacy, one letter and one limited edition at a time.